What Our Customers Say!

  • 5 star ratingOwner, James, gentleman; professional; rectified issues pertaining to series of unsatisfactory experiences per staff, retaining future business for location.

    M. G. Avatar M. G.

    5 star ratingBest bagels in Southern Brooklyn!  They cook them to perfection and have a great list of spreads available as well.... read more

    Anthony A. Avatar Anthony A.

    5 star ratingBest bagels in Town. Everyone always visits asks for a good bagel and we never disappoint them when we take... read more

    Mike D. Avatar Mike D.
  • 5 star ratingWhen it's busy, the line's out the door for good reason. They get everything right. Quick service, everything's fresh, the... read more

    Rita V. Avatar Rita V.

    5 star ratingA nice size deli with plenty of tables to sit and have a quick bite to eat. They have the... read more

    Lauren B. Avatar Lauren B.

    5 star ratingVEGAN CREAM CHEESE! 2 types of vegan cream cheese - scallion & vegetable. And they're both delicious! Rich and creamy... read more

    Morgan S. Avatar Morgan S.
  • 5 star ratingBagel boy has my favorite everything bagel ever.
    If you're lucky you'll get Michelle. Michelle crafts the best bagels period. Get... read more

    Mi S. Avatar Mi S.

    5 star ratingI know people love H&L, but I love Bagel Boy. I don't eat any fancy bagels. I come there for... read more

    Yelper Y. Avatar Yelper Y.

    5 star ratingI come here on weekends for breakfast. Coffee is fresh. I get whole-wheat bagel with cream cheese. The staff is... read more

    Enriko G. Avatar Enriko G.
  • 5 star ratingWithout a doubt the best bagels in the area.  I wish they were closer to me.  There's always a huge... read more

    Lucy O. Avatar Lucy O.

    5 star ratingComing here for years and it's never ever change. Nice. hard working guys r there always trying to help.
    Never... read more

    Alina S. Avatar Alina S.

    5 star ratingThis is the best place to get Bagel's in all of central New Jersey! I declare it now. A couple... read more

    Jit C. Avatar Jit C.
  • 5 star ratingBagels: yes.
    Vegetable cream cheese: yes.
    I'll put up with surly cashiers for those two things. The whitefish is pretty strong, too.

    Matt O. Avatar Matt O.

    5 star ratingWe stopped by here before heading to our cruise. Never really noticed it until my bf mentioned it, and I... read more

    Root E. Avatar Root E.

    5 star ratingLove this place.  Superb bagels and service.  They provide the Brooklyn hometown spice I miss. We appreciate your service.

    Marisol P. Avatar Marisol P.
  • 5 star ratingThere really is no other bagel place better than Bagel Boy. I grew up in the area, and came here... read more

    Jacquelyn W. Avatar Jacquelyn W.

    5 star ratingThere was no line on a Friday morning. I ordered two toasted rainbow bagels with veggie cream cheese, one blueberry... read more

    Sarah K. Avatar Sarah K.

    5 star ratingEasy to say best bagels in Brooklyn.the staff is always so nice and take care of you.always fresh bagels and... read more

    Mitchell M. Avatar Mitchell M.
  • 5 star ratingBest coffee in the neighborhood, by far.
    They save me every morning, when i arrive like clockwork, to order my bacon... read more

    Richard L. Avatar Richard L.

    5 star ratingGreat fresh food but a little pricey. Very clean place with friendly staff . Thank you Bagel Boy

    Shaina A. Avatar Shaina A.

    5 star ratingThis store always has the freshest of everything!  The bagels are the best in Brooklyn!  The salads are awesome.  The... read more

    Sindy C. Avatar Sindy C.
  • 5 star ratingGreat bagels. Great variety. Nice people.  We go all the time.

    Cassandra M. Avatar Cassandra M.

    5 star ratingSome days there's better service(some days it's sucky) but overall best bagel place in this part of Brooklyn! Love the... read more

    Tamara D. Avatar Tamara D.

    5 star ratingI have visited Bagel Boy several times and each time I have come away impressed with the quality of their... read more

    Neil B. Avatar Neil B.
  • 5 star ratingAwesome service, amazing food, adorable cafe! The most consistently good food and service I've been to in NY that doesn't... read more

    Muriel F. Avatar Muriel F.

    5 star ratingComing here since I was a kid, good prices and great bagels+spreads. This morning my bagel was made quicker than... read more

    Sam N. Avatar Sam N.

    5 star ratingTheir bagels and muffins are the best. I had a poppy seed bagel and a lemon poppy muffin, so it... read more

    Dot G. Avatar Dot G.
  • 5 star ratingEvery time I come back to Brooklyn I make an effort to grab bagels at Bagel Boy. Their bagels are... read more

    George A. Avatar George A.

    5 star ratingBest bagels in the area. Crispy on the outside , soft and delicious on the inside. Place can be a... read more

    Bay R. Avatar Bay R.

    5 star ratingEverything here is top notch. You can go with the classic breakfast sandwich, bagel with flavored CC or even plain!... read more

    Matt P. Avatar Matt P.
  • 5 star ratingWoah.  Seriously, I don't even know where to start.
    We got re-routed to JFK instead of BOS (long story) on our... read more

    Nick P. Avatar Nick P.

    5 star ratingOrdered delivery through the yelp app.One of The best bagels in Bay Ridge!Ordered bagels lox & cream cheese and came... read more

    Carlett S. Avatar Carlett S.

    5 star ratingThe best bagel place in Brooklyn hands down. The place is always packed with people but deff worth the wait.... read more

    Ksusha K. Avatar Ksusha K.
  • 5 star ratingPicked up half a dozen bagels and cream cheese before visiting Grandma. Bagels were some of the best I've ever... read more

    Michele Y. Avatar Michele Y.

    5 star ratingHands down best bagel store around. The line is consistent so you know everything is as fresh as possible. Don't... read more

    Sabrina S. Avatar Sabrina S.

    5 star ratingThis place is soooo good. I love their variety of bagels. I usually get a blt and it's delicious there.... read more

    Olichka B. Avatar Olichka B.
  • 5 star ratingI've finally found a bagel shop that reminds me of New York.
    Delicious bagels & spreads. I love their veggie... read more

    Nerisa G. Avatar Nerisa G.

    5 star ratingBagel boy in Brooklyn is just as yummy. Miss brooklyn bagels and breakfast' and this place hits the spot.

    Kathy C. Avatar Kathy C.

    5 star ratingLove the food, the staff and the atmosphere.  Coffee is ok, sandwiches, plates and of course bagels are excellent.  Super friendly

    Robert L. Avatar Robert L.
  • 5 star ratingHands down the absolute best bagels of all time.  I've been coming here for years and whatever bagel I order... read more

    Leonard G. Avatar Leonard G.

    5 star ratingNot only are the bagels and sandwiches delicious but I had Bagel Boy cater my wedding day breakfast for the... read more

    Pea B. Avatar Pea B.

    5 star ratingConsistently good bagels, sandwiches and coffee. I've never been disappointed with anything I got here, and that means a lot... read more

    Alex G. Avatar Alex G.
  • 5 star ratingAbsolutely love this place. The coffee is great the food is always fresh. Their bagels have the perfect amount of... read more

    Crystal M. Avatar Crystal M.

    5 star ratingGreat fast service everything is fresh and delicious highly recommend very friendly love it

    Sandra S. Avatar Sandra S.

    5 star ratingAwesome food. Great service. Kelly, Bridget n staff excellence in creating customers loyalty.  See you again... And again.

    Ahmed B. Avatar Ahmed B.
  • 5 star ratingThey have fresh bagels daily and have unique spread flavors! The place is full of hardworking staff too. Best bagel... read more

    Abigail G. Avatar Abigail G.

    5 star ratingThey're a little out of the way for me... but I don't care. They're great. Buy 12 bagels for $12... read more

    Jenn H. Avatar Jenn H.

    5 star ratingYou can't go wrong with Bagel Boy. A Bay Ridge fave. No matter what time you go it is busy,... read more

    Steven T. Avatar Steven T.
  • 5 star ratingThis is my favorite place to get bagels or a sandwich on the weekends. The food is absolutely delicious, and... read more

    Alisa S. Avatar Alisa S.

    5 star ratingMy nieces and nephew were in town and wanted to try the infamous rainbow bagels! So i turned to yelp... read more

    Linh L. Avatar Linh L.

    5 star ratingI really like this place. I go there for breakfast whenever I get the chance. Bagels of all types and... read more

    Ralph C. Avatar Ralph C.
  • 5 star ratingI love their bagels. I especially love their bacon. But when I come an hour before you close the grill... read more

    Food G. Avatar Food G.

    5 star ratingBeen coming here for years.. The line is always out the door but they have the best bagels around and... read more

    Diana R. Avatar Diana R.

    5 star ratingThis place is outstanding!  Their bagels are the best in Brooklyn (egg everything are my fav)!  Their sandwiches are delicious!... read more

    Shannon C. Avatar Shannon C.
  • 5 star ratingOrdered a tray of food to be sent to a friend. They did an excellent job and were super efficient.... read more

    Colleen M. Avatar Colleen M.

    5 star ratingBagel Boy - the only boy I can always depend on.
    I absolutely love this place. Delicious bagels, massive portions, reasonably... read more

    Mary K. Avatar Mary K.

    5 star ratingBagel Boy in Bay Ridge is absolutely fantastic. The food items? Phenomenal and fresh. The display? Very nice, and so... read more

    Well Well Well B. Avatar Well Well Well B.
  • 5 star ratingComing here for years and it's never ever change. Nice. hard working guys r there always trying to help.
    Never... read more

    Alina S. Avatar Alina S.

    5 star ratingI was treated exceptionally well by the staff. The breakfast sandwiches are fantastic--I had an egg and muenster cheese on... read more

    Carlo D. Avatar Carlo D.

    5 star ratingThis place has the BEST bagels/sandwiches, you name it.
    I remember I used to play hookie when I was attending... read more

    Shonila A. Avatar Shonila A.
  • 5 star ratingLove love love this place . Always my go to bagel spot . Hate the lines but usually worth wait... read more

    Gilan L. Avatar Gilan L.

    5 star ratingBagel Boy is great . Tasty fresh bagels ,deli sandwiches , cookies and muffins . An assortment of different coffees... read more

    Johnny P. Avatar Johnny P.

    5 star ratingThis is the kind of place I'd be a regular at.  It was small but super-clean and well-organized, offering a... read more

    Tina Y. Avatar Tina Y.
  • 5 star ratingBagel Boy in Bay Ridge is absolutely fantastic. The food items? Phenomenal and fresh. The display? Very nice, and so... read more

    William Michael B. Avatar William Michael B.

    5 star ratingYou want best place in all the warld?! This is it! Since this was hot and busy Saturday this place... read more

    Artrm S. Avatar Artrm S.

    5 star ratingCan't beat the cream cheeses or the variety. Very fair prices and you're always taken care of. Special note is... read more

    Igor S. Avatar Igor S.
  • 5 star ratingBest bagels in bay ridge. Their bagels are amazingly not full of carbs. So this place is a great place... read more

    Hell Nah B. Avatar Hell Nah B.

    5 star ratingI've been multiple times on weekends for bagels. Sometimes it's super crowded, others not. But it's worth the (relatively short)... read more

    April H. Avatar April H.

    5 star ratingBagel Boy definitely has the best bagels around. Once you have them you seriously crave them. I love their everything... read more

    Amanda S. Avatar Amanda S.
  • 5 star ratingNothing like a bagel from bagel boy! You don't even need to add anything the bagels alone taste so good.... read more

    Ashley C. Avatar Ashley C.

    5 star ratingJust good old fashioned great bagels, can't get enough of them. My go to place after moving into the area

    Steve O. Avatar Steve O.

    5 star ratingTheir bagels are excellent!  Their everything bagels are my favorite.  I tried one of their cold sandwiches and it was... read more

    Danielle S. Avatar Danielle S.
  • 5 star ratingamazzzziing bagels! try the rainbow one!

    Andrew M. Avatar Andrew M.

    5 star ratingThe people who work there are super friendly!!! the bagels are awesome and the prices are great... I love going... read more

    Amy V. Avatar Amy V.

    5 star ratingThey are the best bagels ever. Most important the service and the owner Richie making you feel special. The place... read more

    Jackie F. Avatar Jackie F.
  • 5 star ratingI just picked up a dozen bagels and end up with 15! With $1.00 each it is a bargain. The... read more

    Maria P. Avatar Maria P.

    5 star ratingI've been coming to bagel boy consistently all my life because their bagels are one to beat.
    Their bagels are... read more

    Ashley S. Avatar Ashley S.

    5 star ratingI've been coming to bagel boy as long as I can remember! Best bagels in south brooklyn! Love their bagels... read more

    Gina P. Avatar Gina P.
  • 5 star rating1. Really good bagels! Soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside. Perfect balance.
    2. Lots of spread options.... read more

    Kathleen T. Avatar Kathleen T.

    5 star ratingI'd say this is the only bagel place I would ever go to, bagels always fresh and made the right... read more

    Max R. Avatar Max R.

    5 star ratingSuper nice staff, really good bagels/sandwiches/paninis! Lots of coffee options! Have done a really nice job for some business breakfasts/lunches... read more

    Cathy L. Avatar Cathy L.
  • 5 star ratingWOW. Had a bagel with cream cheese and it almost weighed 3 lbs haha! I loved it. Great food and... read more

    Kevin M. Avatar Kevin M.

    5 star ratingBagel Boy is an icon of Bay Ridge. Everytime I have an out of state visitor I immediately bring them... read more

    Beatrice G. Avatar Beatrice G.

    5 star ratingBest bagels in entire NYC! Ever since we had bagels from here we don't enjoy any other bagel spot! We... read more

    Hiba S. Avatar Hiba S.
  • 5 star ratingEverything from this place is amazing,my favorite lox w/veg.creamcheese always fresh!

    Anna A. Avatar Anna A.

    5 star ratingGreat bagel sandwich and coffee!!  It's feels like a solid local place.
    Went on a Sunday morning so obviously it was... read more

    Ginger W. Avatar Ginger W.

    5 star ratingMost dependable deli in Bay Ridge. It's clean, delivery is fast, and the food is always fresh. This place is... read more

    Cameron C. Avatar Cameron C.
  • 5 star ratingI no longer live in Old Bridge but this is a go to breakfast spot when I visit! On weekends,... read more

    Sarah K. Avatar Sarah K.

    5 star ratingMy friends and I went here at around 1pm on a Saturday and it was packed- the line went almost... read more

    Gabriella S. Avatar Gabriella S.

    5 star ratingAlways good, fair pricing and pleasant people. I typically get lox on a bagel and portions are perfect.

    Daniel F. Avatar Daniel F.
  • 5 star ratingMy absolute favorite bagels!!  I also love all of the pasta salads and macaroni salad.  Everything is always so fresh... read more

    Jess R. Avatar Jess R.

    5 star ratingTruly an excellent deli. I ended up going almost every day on my last NYC visit, and was more and... read more

    Mark S. Avatar Mark S.

    5 star ratingi came by the place and never have eaten anything like it! WOW i also told my pals in the... read more

    Scott J. Avatar Scott J.
  • 5 star ratingThere is something almost spiritual about the coffee here. Touches my soul with each sip. I prefer this over any... read more

    Nancy A. Avatar Nancy A.

    5 star ratingThis is my absolute favorite place to get a sandwich. Swift service, friendly atmosphere & a wide selection beyond sandwiches.

    Reuben D. Avatar Reuben D.

    5 star ratingall their bagels are excellent, whole wheat everything, garlic,  but the pumpernickel in particular stand out for what seems to... read more

    Keith b. Avatar Keith b.
  • 5 star ratingI am a huge bagel fan. The bagel here are the definition of perfection! They're delicious.  I will be back!!!

    Doris M. Avatar Doris M.

    5 star ratingDelicious bagels, ever since I moved to Bushwick I've struggled to find a bagel store that I enjoy as much.... read more

    Allie S. Avatar Allie S.

    5 star ratingBest breakfast sandwiches in old bridge. When you ask for a scrambled egg, you actually get it scrambled not just... read more

    David A. Avatar David A.
  • 5 star ratingBEST BAGEL PLACE IN BROOKLYN. Huge variety of sandwiches, bagels, wraps, paninis, platters, salads. Staff is very friendly and helpful.... read more

    Alex G. Avatar Alex G.

    5 star ratingBagel boy is my favorite bagel spot in NJ! I always come here for a breakfast sandwich when I visit... read more

    Christie A. Avatar Christie A.

Third Avenue, Brooklyn

Avenue Z, Brooklyn

Old Bridge, New Jersey