What Our Customers Say!

  • 5 star ratingNot only are the bagels and sandwiches delicious but I had Bagel Boy cater my wedding day breakfast for the... read more

    Pea B. Avatar Pea B.

    5 star ratingBest bagels in bay ridge. Their bagels are amazingly not full of carbs. So this place is a great place... read more

    Hell Nah B. Avatar Hell Nah B.

    5 star ratingOwner, James, gentleman; professional; rectified issues pertaining to series of unsatisfactory experiences per staff, retaining future business for location.

    M. G. Avatar M. G.
  • 5 star ratingComing here for years and it's never ever change. Nice. hard working guys r there always trying to help.
    Never... read more

    Alina S. Avatar Alina S.

    5 star ratingHands down the absolute best bagels of all time.  I've been coming here for years and whatever bagel I order... read more

    Leonard G. Avatar Leonard G.

    5 star ratingSuper nice staff, really good bagels/sandwiches/paninis! Lots of coffee options! Have done a really nice job for some business breakfasts/lunches... read more

    Cathy L. Avatar Cathy L.
  • 5 star ratingWhen it's busy, the line's out the door for good reason. They get everything right. Quick service, everything's fresh, the... read more

    Rita V. Avatar Rita V.

    5 star ratingall their bagels are excellent, whole wheat everything, garlic,  but the pumpernickel in particular stand out for what seems to... read more

    Keith b. Avatar Keith b.

    5 star ratingBeen coming here for years.. The line is always out the door but they have the best bagels around and... read more

    Diana R. Avatar Diana R.
  • 5 star ratingamazzzziing bagels! try the rainbow one!

    Andrew M. Avatar Andrew M.

    5 star ratingBest bagels in entire NYC! Ever since we had bagels from here we don't enjoy any other bagel spot! We... read more

    Hiba S. Avatar Hiba S.

    5 star ratingI know people love H&L, but I love Bagel Boy. I don't eat any fancy bagels. I come there for... read more

    Yelper Y. Avatar Yelper Y.
  • 5 star ratingEverything from this place is amazing,my favorite lox w/veg.creamcheese always fresh!

    Anna A. Avatar Anna A.

    5 star ratingJust good old fashioned great bagels, can't get enough of them. My go to place after moving into the area

    Steve O. Avatar Steve O.

    5 star ratingI'd say this is the only bagel place I would ever go to, bagels always fresh and made the right... read more

    Max R. Avatar Max R.
  • 5 star ratingThis place has the BEST bagels/sandwiches, you name it.
    I remember I used to play hookie when I was attending... read more

    Shonila A. Avatar Shonila A.

    5 star ratingWoah.  Seriously, I don't even know where to start.
    We got re-routed to JFK instead of BOS (long story) on our... read more

    Nick P. Avatar Nick P.

    5 star ratingBagels: yes.
    Vegetable cream cheese: yes.
    I'll put up with surly cashiers for those two things. The whitefish is pretty strong, too.

    Matt O. Avatar Matt O.
  • 5 star ratingEvery time I come back to Brooklyn I make an effort to grab bagels at Bagel Boy. Their bagels are... read more

    George A. Avatar George A.

    5 star ratingThis is the best place to get Bagel's in all of central New Jersey! I declare it now. A couple... read more

    Jit C. Avatar Jit C.

    5 star ratingI've been multiple times on weekends for bagels. Sometimes it's super crowded, others not. But it's worth the (relatively short)... read more

    April H. Avatar April H.
  • 5 star ratingI really like this place. I go there for breakfast whenever I get the chance. Bagels of all types and... read more

    Ralph C. Avatar Ralph C.

    5 star ratingGreat bagel sandwich and coffee!!  It's feels like a solid local place.
    Went on a Sunday morning so obviously it was... read more

    Ginger W. Avatar Ginger W.

    5 star ratingLove the food, the staff and the atmosphere.  Coffee is ok, sandwiches, plates and of course bagels are excellent.  Super friendly

    Robert L. Avatar Robert L.
  • 5 star ratingBagel boy has my favorite everything bagel ever.
    If you're lucky you'll get Michelle. Michelle crafts the best bagels period. Get... read more

    Mi S. Avatar Mi S.

    5 star ratingNothing like a bagel from bagel boy! You don't even need to add anything the bagels alone taste so good.... read more

    Ashley C. Avatar Ashley C.

    5 star ratingConsistently good bagels, sandwiches and coffee. I've never been disappointed with anything I got here, and that means a lot... read more

    Alex G. Avatar Alex G.
  • 5 star ratingI just picked up a dozen bagels and end up with 15! With $1.00 each it is a bargain. The... read more

    Maria P. Avatar Maria P.

    5 star ratingSome days there's better service(some days it's sucky) but overall best bagel place in this part of Brooklyn! Love the... read more

    Tamara D. Avatar Tamara D.

    5 star ratingGreat fast service everything is fresh and delicious highly recommend very friendly love it

    Sandra S. Avatar Sandra S.
  • 5 star ratingBest coffee in the neighborhood, by far.
    They save me every morning, when i arrive like clockwork, to order my bacon... read more

    Richard L. Avatar Richard L.

    5 star ratingTheir bagels are excellent!  Their everything bagels are my favorite.  I tried one of their cold sandwiches and it was... read more

    Danielle S. Avatar Danielle S.

    5 star ratingThis place is soooo good. I love their variety of bagels. I usually get a blt and it's delicious there.... read more

    Olichka B. Avatar Olichka B.
  • 5 star ratingAbsolutely love this place. The coffee is great the food is always fresh. Their bagels have the perfect amount of... read more

    Crystal M. Avatar Crystal M.

    5 star ratingWithout a doubt the best bagels in the area.  I wish they were closer to me.  There's always a huge... read more

    Lucy O. Avatar Lucy O.

    5 star ratingGreat fresh food but a little pricey. Very clean place with friendly staff . Thank you Bagel Boy

    Shaina A. Avatar Shaina A.
  • 5 star ratingI've finally found a bagel shop that reminds me of New York.
    Delicious bagels & spreads. I love their veggie... read more

    Nerisa G. Avatar Nerisa G.

    5 star ratingI am a huge bagel fan. The bagel here are the definition of perfection! They're delicious.  I will be back!!!

    Doris M. Avatar Doris M.

    5 star ratingGreat bagels. Great variety. Nice people.  We go all the time.

    Cassandra M. Avatar Cassandra M.
  • 5 star ratingThey are the best bagels ever. Most important the service and the owner Richie making you feel special. The place... read more

    Jackie F. Avatar Jackie F.

    5 star ratingI love their bagels. I especially love their bacon. But when I come an hour before you close the grill... read more

    Food G. Avatar Food G.

    5 star ratingi came by the place and never have eaten anything like it! WOW i also told my pals in the... read more

    Scott J. Avatar Scott J.
  • 5 star ratingOrdered a tray of food to be sent to a friend. They did an excellent job and were super efficient.... read more

    Colleen M. Avatar Colleen M.

    5 star ratingHands down best bagel store around. The line is consistent so you know everything is as fresh as possible. Don't... read more

    Sabrina S. Avatar Sabrina S.

    5 star ratingThere is something almost spiritual about the coffee here. Touches my soul with each sip. I prefer this over any... read more

    Nancy A. Avatar Nancy A.
  • 5 star ratingI was treated exceptionally well by the staff. The breakfast sandwiches are fantastic--I had an egg and muenster cheese on... read more

    Carlo D. Avatar Carlo D.

    5 star ratingI've been coming to bagel boy as long as I can remember! Best bagels in south brooklyn! Love their bagels... read more

    Gina P. Avatar Gina P.

    5 star ratingYou want best place in all the warld?! This is it! Since this was hot and busy Saturday this place... read more

    Artrm S. Avatar Artrm S.
  • 5 star ratingAwesome food. Great service. Kelly, Bridget n staff excellence in creating customers loyalty.  See you again... And again.

    Ahmed B. Avatar Ahmed B.

    5 star ratingThey have fresh bagels daily and have unique spread flavors! The place is full of hardworking staff too. Best bagel... read more

    Abigail G. Avatar Abigail G.

    5 star ratingEasy to say best bagels in Brooklyn.the staff is always so nice and take care of you.always fresh bagels and... read more

    Mitchell M. Avatar Mitchell M.
  • 5 star ratingThe best bagel place in Brooklyn hands down. The place is always packed with people but deff worth the wait.... read more

    Ksusha K. Avatar Ksusha K.

    5 star ratingThis is my favorite place to get bagels or a sandwich on the weekends. The food is absolutely delicious, and... read more

    Alisa S. Avatar Alisa S.

    5 star ratingAwesome service, amazing food, adorable cafe! The most consistently good food and service I've been to in NY that doesn't... read more

    Muriel F. Avatar Muriel F.
  • 5 star ratingDelicious bagels, ever since I moved to Bushwick I've struggled to find a bagel store that I enjoy as much.... read more

    Allie S. Avatar Allie S.

    5 star ratingYou can't go wrong with Bagel Boy. A Bay Ridge fave. No matter what time you go it is busy,... read more

    Steven T. Avatar Steven T.

    5 star ratingPicked up half a dozen bagels and cream cheese before visiting Grandma. Bagels were some of the best I've ever... read more

    Michele Y. Avatar Michele Y.
  • 5 star ratingBagel Boy - the only boy I can always depend on.
    I absolutely love this place. Delicious bagels, massive portions, reasonably... read more

    Mary K. Avatar Mary K.

    5 star ratingThis place is outstanding!  Their bagels are the best in Brooklyn (egg everything are my fav)!  Their sandwiches are delicious!... read more

    Shannon C. Avatar Shannon C.

    5 star ratingThere was no line on a Friday morning. I ordered two toasted rainbow bagels with veggie cream cheese, one blueberry... read more

    Sarah K. Avatar Sarah K.
  • 5 star ratingA nice size deli with plenty of tables to sit and have a quick bite to eat. They have the... read more

    Lauren B. Avatar Lauren B.

    5 star ratingMy absolute favorite bagels!!  I also love all of the pasta salads and macaroni salad.  Everything is always so fresh... read more

    Jess R. Avatar Jess R.

    5 star ratingWe stopped by here before heading to our cruise. Never really noticed it until my bf mentioned it, and I... read more

    Root E. Avatar Root E.
  • 5 star ratingCan't beat the cream cheeses or the variety. Very fair prices and you're always taken care of. Special note is... read more

    Igor S. Avatar Igor S.

    5 star ratingThey're a little out of the way for me... but I don't care. They're great. Buy 12 bagels for $12... read more

    Jenn H. Avatar Jenn H.

    5 star ratingThere really is no other bagel place better than Bagel Boy. I grew up in the area, and came here... read more

    Jacquelyn W. Avatar Jacquelyn W.
  • 5 star ratingMy nieces and nephew were in town and wanted to try the infamous rainbow bagels! So i turned to yelp... read more

    Linh L. Avatar Linh L.

    5 star ratingAlways good, fair pricing and pleasant people. I typically get lox on a bagel and portions are perfect.

    Daniel F. Avatar Daniel F.

    5 star ratingThis is the kind of place I'd be a regular at.  It was small but super-clean and well-organized, offering a... read more

    Tina Y. Avatar Tina Y.
  • 5 star ratingMy friends and I went here at around 1pm on a Saturday and it was packed- the line went almost... read more

    Gabriella S. Avatar Gabriella S.

    5 star ratingBagel boy is my favorite bagel spot in NJ! I always come here for a breakfast sandwich when I visit... read more

    Christie A. Avatar Christie A.

    5 star ratingI no longer live in Old Bridge but this is a go to breakfast spot when I visit! On weekends,... read more

    Sarah K. Avatar Sarah K.
  • 5 star ratingBagel Boy definitely has the best bagels around. Once you have them you seriously crave them. I love their everything... read more

    Amanda S. Avatar Amanda S.

    5 star ratingThe people who work there are super friendly!!! the bagels are awesome and the prices are great... I love going... read more

    Amy V. Avatar Amy V.

    5 star ratingThis store always has the freshest of everything!  The bagels are the best in Brooklyn!  The salads are awesome.  The... read more

    Sindy C. Avatar Sindy C.
  • 5 star ratingOrdered delivery through the yelp app.One of The best bagels in Bay Ridge!Ordered bagels lox & cream cheese and came... read more

    Carlett S. Avatar Carlett S.

    5 star ratingI've been coming to bagel boy consistently all my life because their bagels are one to beat.
    Their bagels are... read more

    Ashley S. Avatar Ashley S.

    5 star ratingBagel Boy is great . Tasty fresh bagels ,deli sandwiches , cookies and muffins . An assortment of different coffees... read more

    Johnny P. Avatar Johnny P.
  • 5 star rating1. Really good bagels! Soft on the inside and crunchy on the outside. Perfect balance.
    2. Lots of spread options.... read more

    Kathleen T. Avatar Kathleen T.

    5 star ratingEverything here is top notch. You can go with the classic breakfast sandwich, bagel with flavored CC or even plain!... read more

    Matt P. Avatar Matt P.

    5 star ratingBEST BAGEL PLACE IN BROOKLYN. Huge variety of sandwiches, bagels, wraps, paninis, platters, salads. Staff is very friendly and helpful.... read more

    Alex G. Avatar Alex G.
  • 5 star ratingComing here for years and it's never ever change. Nice. hard working guys r there always trying to help.
    Never... read more

    Alina S. Avatar Alina S.

    5 star ratingBest breakfast sandwiches in old bridge. When you ask for a scrambled egg, you actually get it scrambled not just... read more

    David A. Avatar David A.

    5 star ratingVEGAN CREAM CHEESE! 2 types of vegan cream cheese - scallion & vegetable. And they're both delicious! Rich and creamy... read more

    Morgan S. Avatar Morgan S.
  • 5 star ratingTheir bagels and muffins are the best. I had a poppy seed bagel and a lemon poppy muffin, so it... read more

    Dot G. Avatar Dot G.

    5 star ratingWOW. Had a bagel with cream cheese and it almost weighed 3 lbs haha! I loved it. Great food and... read more

    Kevin M. Avatar Kevin M.

    5 star ratingBagel boy in Brooklyn is just as yummy. Miss brooklyn bagels and breakfast' and this place hits the spot.

    Kathy C. Avatar Kathy C.
  • 5 star ratingBest bagels in Town. Everyone always visits asks for a good bagel and we never disappoint them when we take... read more

    Mike D. Avatar Mike D.

    5 star ratingMost dependable deli in Bay Ridge. It's clean, delivery is fast, and the food is always fresh. This place is... read more

    Cameron C. Avatar Cameron C.

    5 star ratingI have visited Bagel Boy several times and each time I have come away impressed with the quality of their... read more

    Neil B. Avatar Neil B.
  • 5 star ratingTruly an excellent deli. I ended up going almost every day on my last NYC visit, and was more and... read more

    Mark S. Avatar Mark S.

    5 star ratingBagel Boy is an icon of Bay Ridge. Everytime I have an out of state visitor I immediately bring them... read more

    Beatrice G. Avatar Beatrice G.

Third Avenue, Brooklyn

Avenue Z, Brooklyn

Old Bridge, New Jersey